New York Pizzeria

Discover authentic New York-style pizza at New York Pizzeria in Waterville, NY. Enjoy delicious chicken riggies, meatball sliders, garlic knots, wings, subs, and more in a family-owned restaurant with generous portions and classic NY flavors. Call us at +1 315-841-8898!

Welcome to New York Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria

Located at 111 W Main St, Waterville, New York, New York Pizzeria offers an authentic taste of New York's culinary delight. This family-owned pizza restaurant emphasizes generous portion sizes and a diverse menu that caters to every palate. Customers rave about the chicken riggies and meatball sliders, while garlic knots and fish fry keep people coming back for more. Perfect for families and friends, the cozy atmosphere invites laughter and conversation.

Stop by for a slice or bring home a pie to share. Whether it's your first visit or a regular stop, New York Pizzeria has something special waiting for you.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

111 W Main St, Waterville, NY 13480, United States

Phone

+1 315-841-8898

About

The Culinary Story

New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria

New York Pizzeria has become a beloved local gem since opening its doors. The commitment to quality shines through in every dish, from their cheesy pizzas to hearty subs. Offering a comforting blend of classic recipes and modern twists, this restaurant has managed to capture the essence of New York-style pizza. Locals particularly enjoy the specialty pizzas such as the Meat Lovers and Chicken Bacon Ranch, both bursting with flavor. The menu also features wheat-friendly options to suit different dietary requirements, ensuring everyone feels welcome.

One of the highlights of dining here is the ambiance, which combines a rustic pizzeria feel with homey touches.

Walls adorned with colorful paintings reflect the city’s vibrant culture while adding warmth to the setting. Families often bring their little ones to share a slice and bond over their favorite dishes. The restaurant thrives on community, hosting pizza specials on holidays and local events, making it feel like an extended family gathering.

Convenient hours and accessible locations contribute to its popularity. Busy peak times include Friday evenings when there's a vibrant buzz in the air as families and friends gather for delicious pies and signature wings. For those looking to avoid the rush, the best times to visit are earlier in the day, especially during lunchtime between 11 AM and 2 PM.

With something for everyone, from appetizers to delectable desserts like Cannoli and Grinch Cake, New York Pizzeria truly caters to its guests' cravings. Plus, the rich variety in the menu ensures that you'll be back again and again, adding to the sense of community and customer loyalty.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3-7:30 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

New York Pizzeria stands out in the heart of Waterville with its mouthwatering menu and excellent service. With 112 delicious dishes ranging from appetizers to desserts, there's always something new to try. Popular options include the flavorful Buffalo Chicken Antipasto and the satisfying homemade lasagna, each crafted from the finest ingredients. The restaurant accommodates large groups and families, making it a great choice for any gathering. Expect quality service, especially during peak times like Friday evenings when the energy really buzzes. Come during quieter hours for a more relaxed experience and get to know the friendly staff who treat every guest like family.

New York Pizzeria

The exterior of New York Pizzeria is inviting, with bright signage that beckons you to come in. Nestled on W Main St, this cozy eatery boasts a welcoming vibe that makes it hard to walk past. Ideal for gatherings and celebrations, the outdoor seating allows guests to enjoy fresh air while savoring their favorite dishes. Whether sharing a pizza pie under the sun or enjoying a family dinner, the atmosphere feels like a slice of home amidst Waterville's bustle.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

This may just be the best pizza I've ever had and for a ridiculously low price. We got 2 slices of pizza, 2 meatball sliders, and 2 drinks for right around $18. We were both stuffed. The service was great. The atmosphere is cheesy, but in the best way possible. We are visiting from Colorado and this was a surprise I was not expecting!! Highly recommend!!

J
Jessica

This pizzeria is perfect, the food is exceptional, with large portions and being delicious. The staff is very helpful and quick serving your food. It also has a large indoor eating section for a pizzeria. I would never not recommend this place.

C
Collin S.

Had some of the best food was really good I'll be going there from now on

D
Douglas S.

I was driving through Waterville and noticed this pizzeria. Stopped in for a slice and it was very very good. I was greeted instantly by the pizza maker and my slice was more than perfect. I will definitely stop back again on my next time through Waterville

M
Matt P.

Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint.

J
Joe L.

We moved to the area about a year ago and tried out a few of the local pizza places. After a lot of not so good pizza, finally found NY Pizzeria in Waterville. It is consistently excellent. Toppings are generous. Food is yummy! Service is small town great! Service is personal and outstanding, whether it's the owners or the staff. This place is always slammed, yet they are happy to greet you, politely take payment, and say good bye when you leave. Yesterday I ordered a pizza with extra sauce on one half. My crazy aunt likes lots of sauce! They mentioned adding it on the side, so I went with a whole pizza with sauce. Then, I got there. The owner showed me how I could tell which side had the extra sauce. They did it! Half extra, half regular. We've had multiple subs, appetizers, slices, garlic knots, and whole pizzas. Everything is always consistently yummy. I don't know they do it, given how busy this place is. Their systems work! These people are the best! I hope to come back to this place for years!

A
Aaron S.